Sunday, October 11, 2009

#71: The Other (Robert Mulligan, 1972)


Director Robert Mulligan, who died last year at the age of 83, had a long and varied career, though he's still somewhat underrated. A master craftsman who applied his skill, good taste, and sharply detailed eye to a variety of genres, Mulligan brought a strong sense of location, subtle but beautiful shot compositions, and a knack for picking great cinematographers and editors to his films. His most famous film is his 1962 adaptation of Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird, but my favorite Mulligan film is the project immediately following Mockingbird, Love with the Proper Stranger, a beautiful black and white urban drama/romantic comedy hybrid starring Steve McQueen and Natalie Wood. Even his overly sentimental final film, Man in the Moon, starring a young Reese Witherspoon, boasted a lived-in setting, fine performances, and subtly compelling imagery.

Mulligan made dramas, comedies, crime thrillers, and Westerns. The Other is his only horror film, and it's a strange one. The screenplay by Tom Tryon, based on his novel, has a lot of problems, including mawkish sentimentality, overblown and stagy dialogue, and some predictability. The actors have a tough time convincingly putting this dialogue across, particularly the child-actor twins Chris and Martin Udvarnoky and the late Uta Hagen. The German-born, Wisconsin-raised Hagen's Russian accent is weak and distracting (much like Pierce Brosnan's French accent in Nomads), which is particularly disappointing considering Hagen's pedigree. Primarily a stage actress and acting teacher, Hagen's pupils included Jason Robards, Al Pacino, Matthew Broderick, Sigourney Weaver, and Jack Lemmon, so I feel foolish criticizing her performance. She obviously knew what she was doing, but I found her awkward in this film. So far, it sounds like I didn't care for this movie, but that's not the case. Despite my many misgivings, The Other contains several wonderfully creepy scenes, a great location, Mulligan's excellent shot compositions, and, as always with Mulligan, expert cinematography and editing. It's a frustrating film, full of great and terrible things, but certainly worth seeing.

Fitting snugly in the rural American Gothic mold, The Other takes place in the old, weird America best exemplified in the early folk and blues songs on Harry Smith's Anthology of American Folk Music. Set in the 1930s on a small New England farm, the film focuses on the large, extended family living there, particularly a pair of twin boys. They are joined by hired hands and their families, their Russian grandmother, a cousin, some aunts and uncles (including a young John Ritter), and their half-mad, frail mother who is still in mourning for her dead husband. The twins, Niles and Holland, spend most of their time together. This isn't a good thing, because Holland is on the evil side of the movie twin spectrum and is probably responsible for his father's death. Niles, seemingly, is a goody-two-shoes who is very close to his grandmother. Just to make things weirder, Niles has a form of extra-sensory perception taught to him by his grandmother. Called "the game," it allows Niles to mentally step into another person's or animal's body and experience whatever he, she, or it experiences. The summer drags on, bad things sometimes happen, and the boys visit a traveling carnival's freakshow. Bad things continue to happen, including a nasty incident involving a pitchfork hidden in a pile of hay. Several scenes between grandmother and grandson pile on the drippy sentimental gloop, but are nicely offset by memorably dark setpieces involving a loony neighbor, the freak show, and a missing baby, leading to an inevitable but memorable conclusion.

Though Tom Tryon's screenplay was the weakest thing about the movie, his life story is fascinating. The Connecticut-born Tryon began his career as an actor in live-action Disney movies, eventually becoming a movie star and tabloid heartthrob. Tryon became disillusioned with acting in the 1960s, in no small part due to being fired in front of his visiting parents by Otto Preminger on the set of The Cardinal before being rehired shortly thereafter. Tryon quit acting and reinvented himself as a writer of horror, science fiction, and mystery novels. Surprisingly, the handsome movie star turned genre author reinvention worked, and many of his books became bestsellers. Alongside a handful of TV and movie adaptations, his novel Fedora was turned into a criminally underrated film by Billy Wilder. The openly gay Tryon dated both a cast member of A Chorus Line and a porn star and, bizarrely, invented an imaginary lover named Patrick Norton who inspired most of his male characters. He died in 1991 from stomach cancer.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

i don't agree with your opinion and synopsis of the movie, THE OTHER. most books turned movie are weak in one way or another and this was no different in that regard! the book was great in my opinion and so was the movie. all of the akwardness in front of the camera only went to make this horror movie more horrible and almost believable. i did not like the remake with macauley calkin as well as this versiin. it had a better script, better cast of actors and even a better setting but it did not come together as well. the young twins who played the twins were more believable as terrible boys. also regarding ada hagen russian accent, i know russian people who talked exactly as ada did. perhaps you think that all people in russia speak classical russian, if so you are very mistaken! many people speak like ada did. i think that she was a genius in her portrayal of the russian grandmother to niles.

this is of course my opinion!

sign me as,
a big fan of "The Other" and of the late Thomas Tryon